In today’s evolving job market, companies often engage workers in various capacities, including as independent contractors and employees. While both roles can provide significant contributions to a company’s operations, they also have distinct legal and financial implications for both parties involved. Understanding the differences between independent contractors, employees and the even rarer dependent contractors is an important consideration for businesses and workers alike.

Definition and Control

The most important day-to-day distinction between independent contractors and employees is in the degree of control exerted over their work. Employees typically work under the direct supervision and control of their employers. Generally, employees are held out as being part of the company and may be listed on the company website or provided with a company e-mail address. 

In contrast, independent contractors have more autonomy over their work. They retain control over how the price they negotiate for work, performance of tasks and the schedule they follow.  Furthermore, independent contractors often utilize their own tools or equipment, may hire their own workers, work without supervision or even sub-contract work to another party.  They may also be held out as totally independent parties, often not appearing in any company website, social media nor having contact information related to the hiring company.

Taxation and Benefits

Tax obligations also differ significantly between independent contractors and employees. Employers withhold income taxes, EI, CPP and other deductions from employees’ paycheques. Additionally, employers often provide benefits such as health insurance, retirement plans, and paid time off to employees. Conversely, independent contractors are responsible for paying their own taxes, including self-employment tax, and they do not receive benefits from the hiring company.

Legal Protections

In Ontario, employees benefit from various legal protections and entitlements under the Employment Standards Act, 2000 that independent contractors do not typically receive, such as the requirement to give notice of termination, breaks, limits on hours of work, over time, various job protected leaves, vacation pay, holiday pay among other statute required Entitlements. However, independent contractors would not gain the benefit of any of these protections or entitlements unless expressly stated in their contracts.

Dependent Contractors

With all these distinctions there is a grey area between the space occupied by independent contractors and employees known as the dependent contractor.   While these workers are not considered to be employees, the defining characteristic of this segment of contractors is that they derive a substantial portion of their income from one party, such that they are essentially reliant upon that company for their entire income. Legally, dependent contractors have an enhanced entitlement to “reasonable notice” of a termination of their contract compared to independent contractors, as the law determines that their economic dependence would entitle them to this right.  

Distinguishing between independent contractors and employees is critical for both businesses and workers to ensure compliance with employment legislation, taxation requirements and other legal protections and entitlements. Misclassification can result in legal consequences, financial liabilities, and misunderstandings.

While the distinctions can be identified by a multiuse of factors, it is important to point out that no one factor is determinative. The ultimate determination of the employee or contractor status of a worker is always done on a case-by-case analysis of the specific circumstances for that worker to company relationship.

By comprehending the disparities between independent contractors and employees, businesses and workers can foster productive working relationships while adhering to legal and financial obligations.

More information?  We’re here to help – [email protected]

This WARDS LAWYERS PC publication is for general information only. It is not legal advice, nor is it intended to be. Specific or more information may be necessary before advice could be provided for your particular circumstances.

Scroll to Top